No, you cannot shoot a porch pirate in Florida. Florida allows deadly force to protect property only to prevent a forcible felony, and taking a package from a porch is theft, not a forcible felony. Even when package theft is charged as a felony, it does not involve the force or violence that would justify shooting or threatening to shoot.
Section 776.031 lets a person use force, except deadly force, to stop someone interfering with personal property, and limits deadly force to preventing the imminent commission of a forcible felony. Section 776.08 lists forcible felonies, such as robbery, burglary and aggravated battery, and theft is not on it. Section 812.014 treats a package taken from a home’s unenclosed porch as theft, a felony when the item is worth $40 or more.
The facts can change the answer. If the thief threatens someone with a weapon, the situation becomes self-defense under 776.012, which turns on an imminent threat of death or great bodily harm, not on the package. A thief who breaks into the house or an enclosed area may be committing burglary. The limitation is timing: once the thief is walking or driving away, there is no imminent threat left, and pointing a gun can itself lead to charges.
The practical response is to stay inside, record what the doorbell camera shows and report it, because a theft charge is how the package gets paid for. The guide to whether porch piracy is a felony in Florida covers penalties and prevention. Neighborhoods with repeat thefts often add visible security patrol services during the holiday delivery season.